Employers abandoned duty of care during Storm Ophelia

The storm has passed. Sadly, three families have lost loved ones, but those of us who have survived unscathed can breathe a sigh of relief that we did.

While relieved, though, many people are furious at the recklessness shown by employers towards the lives – the lives, not the wellbeing – of their staff. On Sunday night as Ireland was expecting its worst storm in living memory with some of the highest winds ever recorded, the announcement came that schools, colleges and creches would close. Shortly after, many employers contacted their staff to tell them not to attend work.

Many more, however, didn’t. And they didn’t because they are not legally obliged to. There is no legal framework governing the position during emergency situations, and if the most severe weather alert in living memory wasn’t an emergency, then I don’t know what is.


Although Dublin wasn’t badly hit, the scenes in much of the country were like something out of a Hollywood disaster movie. A whole avenue of majestic ancient trees was felled on Cork City’s Marina. Rooftops flew wildly through the air in Cork city suburbs. Cobh, with a population of 13,000, was cut off from the mainland for much of the day, with emergency services unable to access the island. A nurse in Waterford was killed when a tree fell on her car. A man in Tipperary was killed when a tree fell on him as he tried to clear a road. Another man, in Louth, was killed when a tree fell on his car. He was returning from work at the time, having been sent home.

On Monday as I took calls to our radio show from people throughout the city and county who were justifiably worried, it became clear that a huge number of employers had put their profit margins before the lives of their employees. With the unprecedented warnings in place, it should have been clear to everybody that Monday was not a dayto take chances.

But many employers, including semi-states, major retailers, and delivery companies, chose to ignore the warnings. Some didn’t contact staff at all, and others sent mealy-mouthed texts telling people to travel safely. There was no travelling safely on Monday once the wind picked up, but employers put the onus on staff to be the ‘awkward one’ who wouldn’t travel.

Work is precarious these days, and most of the people I spoke to who were affected by this are far from permanent and pensionable. Zero hours workers and contractors were left in a position where not attending work would be a black mark against them when it came to getting additional hours or renewed contracts.

For those who were brought in only to be told to leave again, the situation was worse. Most of the workplaces that opened on Monday morning were closed at a later stage – only to send staff out into the height of winds that were tearing down roofs and uprooting trees. Some were trapped at work for the day, with others trapped miles from home overnight because their return was blocked by fallen trees.

That was the worst of both worlds – they won’t be paid for the time they didn’t officially work, and most companies will not compensate them for overnight expenses.

There is no legal entitlement to pay if staff are told to stay at home in an emergency. For small businesses, that may be understandable – a day closed with no money coming in can mean no money to pay wages. For larger companies with healthy profit margins, it would be good practice to pay, given how rarely this happens.

But as always the buck has to stop with government. There currently is no entitlement to social welfare for emergency days either. Those of us in decently paid permanent jobs might scoff at the idea of claiming social welfare for a single day’s lost income, but for someone in a low paid contract job, a day’s lost pay is a crisis. It would be a small measure, applied rarely, but it would allow people to make a call on their own safety when employers forget their duty of care.



One comment

  1. Hi Dee

    I quite agree with you there, this is something which needs to be taken out of the hands of the employers. My husband works in the Naval Dockyard in Haulbowline, which you can probably see from your house. The Dept of Defence only sends out emergency warnings to naval personnel, they do not contact the civilians working in the dockyard. The system on Monday last was that all workers had to go down to the pier at the usual time, 7.30am, in order to be formally told whether the boats were running. Some workers drove around and accessed the dockyard from the bridge. The dockyard was closed at 9am and everyone was sent home. Since Haulbowline is very vulnerable in bad weather (the bridge is dangerous in high winds) this was a ridiculous system. The government had issued the strongest possible warning regarding weather and its own department decided to disregard it. I highly doubt there was much productive work achieved between 8 and 9 that morning.

    I reiterate what I said on air with PJ, there needs to be legislation brought in covering every possible eventuality for extreme weather conditions, laws which would come into force automatically when the alert is issued and for the timeframe forecast. These laws should cover businesses, emergency services, schools, colleges, churches, the homeless, extra stocks of bottled water, batteries, candles, matches, bread, milk, baby formula and other essentials brought in ahead of time, recreational activities and access to beaches, piers etc. drainage in flood risk areas and I’m sure there are many more issues of which I have not thought.

    Anyone needlessly putting themselves at risk by entering the sea or climbing up a mountain should be liable to prosecution, anyone disregarding the instructions of police to vacate seafront areas should be liable to be arrested and prosecuted. Our emergency services, police, ambulance, fire brigade and coast guard should not have to risk their own safety for people engaging in non essential activities.

    Thanks for highlighting this. Dee.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s