Compromise will hurt services

Compromise will hurt services

Conflicting statements from the Government and the unions over the last few days have left most of us in a state of some confusion. The fact that they are talking again, rather than issuing tit-for-tat hollow threats, is to be welcomed, but the subject and focus of these talks are something to be wondered at.

A number of weeks ago I wrote about a campaign run by the public service unions that was disingenuous at best, and at worst cynical and dishonest. I won’t go over old ground, but the campaign in question featured stock images of a fictitious sick baby (‘Laura’) and the claim that the child needed services more than the Government needed to cut them.

And what has happened since? One public service strike, which caused a lot of hassle (for non-public service parents in particular, many of whom lost a day’s pay in order to stay at home and mind their kids). Widespread flooding across the country, throughout which public service workers have been admirably diligent and dedicated. And now, talks which have seemingly resulted in a decision not to cut their pay, but to cut the amount of time they work.

I may be getting something wrong here, but will this not impact directly on the level of services being offered to ‘Laura’ and others like her?

It’s not fair to blame public sector workers for the disaster the country is in. And if you follow this line of reasoning, it’s not fair to cut their pay either. But companies across the country have already done this, and private sector workers, most of whom did not get any great benefit from the boom, have already taken the pain.

I have great admiration for most public servants. I could never be a nurse, or a teacher – I simply don’t have those skills. But the unions are doing their members a disservice by talking out of both sides of their mouths.

Unions represent their members. They do not represent anyone else – sick babies, old people or flood victims. This is evidenced by the proposal to cut days worked, which will have a clear and major impact on services provided, especially those in key front line areas, where staff are already stretched.

The Government and unions have been uniquely short-sighted in seeing this as a solution. As one private sector friend of mine suggested yesterday, why not reduce public sector sick pay to the statutory level that private sector workers have? This would decrease the amount of absenteeism and make a hug saving. Some imagination would not go amiss.

Another public sector strike would merely have served to deepen the divide between public and private sector workers, when we really are in this together. Let’s just hope a more imaginative and equitable solution can be found.


One comment

  1. I've worked in the public service and I've experienced first hand situations where money is completely wasted. I agree that there are many excellent public workers and I've seen dilligent and hardworking people also but the way that the service is run hemorraghes money. Savings can be made in the public sector by running it more like the private sector. Until it becomes streamlined and more efficient and accountable solutions like unpaid leave will not work. I once worked with a girl who had very little actual work to do, in fairness she turned up on time, put in a day's work and would leave. As she didn't have much to do she used to create pointless work for herself including ordering stationary that was not needed. There were only three of us in the office yet we had enough post its, pens, foolscaps etc to last for about 10 years. The orders were never questioned, simply signed off. This is just a small example of one office in one huge organisation but if this goes on at this level….how many more items are being signed off without being questioned? The major problem the country is experiencing is that we can't afford to pay our bills, why can't we make the public service bill smaller by taking simple steps to be more efficient rather than wage cuts. After three years in that organisation I had to leave and I now work in the private sector. I'm lucky to have a job and I work hard, I'm accountable and I have to justify my work and my many in the public sector justify theirs? Lets stop with the complaining, roll the sleeves up and get on with it, both in the private and public sectors. Surley the end goal is one we should work together on?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s